I just traded in my 2007 Honda CR-V on a 2011 Edge. The CR-V gave us no service problems over the 4-1/2 years, but we do a lot of driving and the CR-V was frustrating for two reasons. First, the ride is firm, the engine is noisy and the seats are hard - we really got tired driving on trips. Second, the fuel economy is disappointing for a 4-cylinder, low powered economy vehicle. We'd generally get 19 or 20 around town and were lucky to get 26 on trips. The 2011 Edge V6 is a dream to drive by comparison. Hopefully the fuel economy will be as advertised.