My wife did the same thing to one of her wheels on her 2009 Edge limited' hers came with the 20" already. So I bought her a new set of after market wheels and tires. Then she hit and wreaked one of them also which cost me another $560 in addition to the $2,000 wheel package.
Anyway I now have the four wheels and tires with the one scraped cover on one of them in my storage shed that I would like to get rid of. Like you, I have been looking for just one so I could sell the whole set but wow they are costly.
If you want to make me an offer for the set that may be an opion for you then you would have two more good backups in case your wife hits another pot hole or curb.
Let me know!
