Ok, I took my car in after the AWD warning light came on and the acceleration dropped....the dealership was able to mimic the issue and they found.... (drum roll please....) that it was the throttle body that needed replacement! It stumped my dealership because when they hooked it up to the computer to see if any problems registered, it said that everything was fine and there were no issues.
Knowing that it was the throttle body makes sense because I've had issues with accelerating from the get-go and I found that when I filled up with premium gas performance was better. Now after getting the throttle body replaced I find that I no longer have issues with accelerating with regular gas.
Crisis averted!