Ray, not sure why you think I'm grumpy, nothing was intended to come across that way.
I have an Ellisys USB protocol analyzer but unfortunately this model only tracks the data lines. Nevertheless, I'm an engineer and do have more than a simplified understanding of the technology.
I've gathered four 12v usb adapters: 500ma, 1a, 2a and QC 2.0. The phone shows "USB" charging for the 500ma, "AC" for the 1 and 2a, "Fast" for the QC and "USB" for the Edge's ports.
I understand that the phone (or any other usb device for that matter) will only draw what it needs depending on the state of the device at any given point in time. In this case, the state of the device is exactly the same for each tested port, except for trivial differences in remaining battery capacity. Same cable, same running apps, same screen brightness, same radios enabled, etc.
Seems reasonable to conclude that the Edge port is only capable of 500ma. Otherwise, why would the phone not recognize this (and only this) port as an "AC" port, when it supposedly can deliver up to 2a?
If the Edge's "smart" port really is trying to be smart and only advertises itself as being capable of what the phone needs at that point in time, then how would the phone know it could draw more when it needs to?
I have no problem admitting when I'm wrong, so if my assumption here is wrong, where am I going wrong?