I'm sure with the proper surface preperation and the right paint it can be done. I too am thinking of making a change to this area inside my Edge as well. The reflection isn't an issue for me but there are some areas where the brushed finish has started to wear away. I will probably purchase one of the dash kits in a carbon fiber finish though. I had a carbon fiber dash kit in my '04 F250 Lariat and I loved it and received many compliments on it as well. I know you said you don't want to go in that direction yet but the dash kits come in many different finishes that would look great inside the Edge regardless of which interior color you have, just my opinion. Good luck with whatever decision you make.