I have had three Subaru Outbacks in the past,97,00 and a 2010. I totaled the 2010 Subaru after owning it for five months and could not make a deal on a new one. Test drove the Edge and was very impressed on how it handled. Gas milage was better with the 2.5 engine on the Subaru 29 mpg. I am getting 23 so far on my Edge Limited AWD. As for the AWD it is just like the Subaru. I live in Syracuse NY and we get lots of snow. It drives great on the 18" tires that came on the vehicle. I also like the added room inside. Both are nice cars but I would go for the edge just for all of the fun toys that come with it. I am very happy with the Sync system and Navigation along with the sound system. Good luck to you.............